Re-Write? or Re-Wrong?

April 1st, 2010

I wouldn’t normally post a review on a Thursday but today was sort of mandatory (I have read 3 books and haven’t written a review on any of them… I’m afraid I’m going to get them confused in my head) So, in lieu of “It’s a Tween Thing,” I’ll just write a review of a book that involves teens. (Sounds like a fair trade right?)

“Beastly” is a story we have read a hundred time…seen a hundred times… and will most likely read, and see 100 times more before it has been pummeled into little bitty unrecognizable pieces.

Ladies and gentleman, let me introduce you to the latest literary version of Beauty and the Beast.

You would think after so many versions someone would come up with a unique twist right? Apparently not, which I have to say baffles me more than I would like to admit.  Here is an outline for a story that has been handed down for hundreds of years, boy is arrogant, girl is nice/naive, witch thinks boy should learn a lesson, cast a spell and BAM! Ugliness ensues. There are a number of different rules/regulations/requirements to break the spell but the most important is true love…BAM spell broken!

So why is it so hard to shake things up a bit? Regardless of your thoughts, dear authors, you can very easily keep an intended plot line AND explore the alternatives in the quest to get there.

I’m not saying that “Beastly” was uninteresting… the story is a classic for a reason, but the fact that the screenwriters for its up coming movie adaptation had more creativity, in a minute long teaser trailer, than an author (that has 7 novels under her belt) did is almost embarrassing.

“Alex Flinn’s” writing was, in places, exasperatingly juvenile, and there were random chat-room sequences that were awkward, unnecessary, and out of place.  The character development was also top heavy, listing pages of detail for “Beast” but in return only offering the audience a few brief paragraphs for Lindy (the girl.) It is important for authors of YA Literature to understand that even though their novel is “intended” for a youthful audience, their WRITING doesn’t need to reflect it.

Now, keeping all of the negativity in mind, the above rant is not to say the book wasn’t an enjoyable read, it’s just one that has to be read for what it is.  It’s a read that takes a few hours and not much thought, which might be just what the doctor ordered on days of endless stress.

Here is my recommendation… If you are having a bad day and want to relax with a book you don’t have to concentrate all that hard on, buy it, otherwise, wait for the movie. (God I hate saying that.)

Happy reading my fellow Kindle-ites and remember: if there is a will there is a way, sometimes it just takes a fresh perspective.

For a complete book description click image

(2/5)

Movie Trailer

Guest Review – A Kiss In Time

January 25th, 2010

Guest Reviewer – Nicole

Having absolutely adored Beastly, I was quick to grab Flinn’s newest fairy tale rewrite off the shelf when I found it by chance (the fact that there wasn’t a hold list going shocked me).

Flinn’s writing with each book she writes just keeps improving, but compared to her old stuff, which involved real life issues, well I’m an escapist reader so it’s not even a fair comparison, A Kiss in Time and Beastly are light years better than her other young adult novels.

Sleeping Beauty wakes up in the 21st century by the kiss of her one true love–after sleeping for 300 years. Only this time Talia is a bratty princess and isn’t used to things not going her way.

This book could not have been any better, it was perfect and nearly impossible to close, that is until you flip the last page.

To say I loved this book is an understatement–I am addicted to this book.

For Complete Book Details Click Image

(5/5)

RSS Feed

  • Digg
  • Delicious
  • Furl
  • Stumble
  • Technorati
  • Yahoo